Shelter in Place
Pandemic Prudentialism and Park Space in Toronto/Tkaronto
Keywords:
pandemic, COVID-19, prudentialism, park space, encampment, homelessnessAbstract
In this article, we interrogate the representation and construction of public park space in a settler colonial city: Toronto/Tkaronto. First, we draw on the relationship between urban neoliberalism and prudentialism to demonstrate the way public health authorities in Toronto/Tkaronto promoted a neoliberal ideology of prudentialism that emphasized individual action (e.g., social distancing, personal hygiene, sheltering in place) in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Second, we consider the extent to which this response congealed and combined with broader anxieties that were used to manage more than the virus. We focus specifically on the way these anxieties took hold in public park space, and in particular the response to encampment communities. We theorize prudentialism, as an instrument of the white settler state, to interrogate the twin processes of organized abandonment and organized violence (Gilmore 2022), which were made visible in the treatment of unhoused people amidst the pandemic in an affluent and seemingly progressive city in a nation now known as Canada. Recognizing that COVID-19 has afflicted global cities marred by real estate speculation and the continual reliance on the commodification of Indigenous Land, which has made homelessness and urban displacement a lived condition for some, we argue that public health crises result not from—and thereby cannot be solved by—prudential responsibilization, but from the willful ignorance of the neoliberal, capitalist white settler [real estate] state (Stein 2019).
References
Ali, S. Harris. 2010. “Tuberculosis, homelessness, and the politics of mobility.” Canadian Journal of Urban Research 19 (2): 80-107.
August, Martine. 2022. “Housing in Canada: A summary report for the Office of the Federal Housing Advocate.” The Office of the Federal Housing Advocate, Canadian Human Rights Commission. https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2023/ccdp-chrc/HR34-7-2022-eng.pdf
Hatlem, Doug J., Noa Mendelsohn Aviv and Geetha Philipupillai. 2022. “Two Metres: the Legal Challenge.” In Displacement City: Fighting for Health and Homes in a Pandemic, edited by Greg Cook and Cathy Crowe, 224-239. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Baral, Stefan, Andrew Bond, Andrew Boozary, Eva Bruketa, Nika Elmi, Deirdre Freiheit, S. Monty Ghosh, Marie E. Goyer, Aaron M. Orkin, Jamie Patel, Tim Richter, Angela Robertson, Christy Sutherland, Tomislav Svoboda, Jeffrey Turnbull, Alexander Wong and Alice Zhu. 2021. “Seeking shelter: homelessness and COVID-19.” Facets 6 (1): 925-958.
Black, Derrick, Michelle Plourd, Matina Koumoudouros, Ashley Ellis, Nancy Fisher, Mark Medas, Joan Smith, Paul Kager, Raymond Martin, Mark Baratta, Marie Graves, Katelyn Bowman, John Cullen, Daniel Cunningham, Toronto Overdose Prevention Society and Ontario Coalition Against Poverty v. Toronto (City), ONSC 6398, CV-20-644217 (October 1, 2020). https://www.socialrights.ca/2020/Black%20v%20Toronto%20encampment%20decn.pdf.
Blomley, Nicholas. 2003. Unsettling the city: Urban land and the politics of property. New York: Routledge.
Blomley, Nicholas, Alexandra Flynn, and Marie-Eve Sylvestre. 2020. “Governing the belongings of the precariously housed: A critical legal geography.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 16: 165-181.
Boucher, Lisa M., Zoë Dodd, Samantha Young, Abeera Shahid, Ahmed Bayoumi, Michelle Firestone and Claire E. Kendall. 2022. “They have their security, we have our community”: Mutual support among people experiencing homelessness in encampments in Toronto during the COVID-19 pandemic.” SSM-Qualitative Research in Health, 100163.
Brown, Rebecca CH, Hannah Maslen and Julian Savulescu. 2019. “Against Moral Responsibilisation of Health: Prudential Responsibility and Health Promotion”. Public Health Ethics 2 (2): 114-129.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC]. 2020. “Interim Guidance on People Experiencing Unsheltered Homelessness.” May 10, 2020. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/homeless-shelters/unsheltered-homelessness.html.
Castel, Robert. 1991. From dangerousness to risk. In The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality, edited by Graham Burchell, Colin Gordon and Peter Miller, 283-298. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Chapman, Chris and A.J. Withers. 2019. A Violent History of Benevolence: Interlocking Oppression in the Moral Economies of Social Working. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Chua, Charmaine, Travis Linnemann, Dean Spade, Jasmine Syedullah and Geo Maher. 2023. Police abolition. Contemporary Political Theory, 1-32.
City of Toronto. 2004. “Our Common Grounds: Parks and Recreation Strategic Plan.” http://publiccommons.ca/public/uploads/cityoftoronto/OCG.pdf.
City of Toronto. 2020a. “City of Toronto closing playgrounds and other parks amenities to stop the spread of COVID-19.” https://www.toronto.ca/news/city-of-toronto-closing-playgrounds-and-other-parks-amenities-to-stop-the-spread-of-covid-19/.
City of Toronto. 2020b. “Emergency Order No. 1: To impose regulations requiring physical distancing within Parks and Public Squares.” https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/bylaws/2020/law0322.pdf.
City of Toronto. 2020c. “Active COVID-19 Outbreaks in Toronto Shelters, April 24, 2020.” https://www.toronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/9548-Shelters-with-Case-and-Death-Count-Apr-24.pdf.
City of Toronto. 2018. “Street Needs Assessment.” https://www.toronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/99be-2018-SNA-Results-Report.pdf.
City of Toronto. 2021. “Street Needs Assessment.” https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2021/ec/bgrd/backgroundfile-171729.pdf.
Connolly, Creighton, S. Harris Ali, and Roger Keil. 2020. “On the relationships between COVID-19 and extended urbanization.” Dialogues in Human Geography 10 (2): 213-216.
Cook, Greg, Cathy Crowe, and Robyn Maynard. 2022. Displacement City: Fighting for Health and Homes in a Pandemic. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Crowe, Cathy. 2019. A knapsack full of dreams: Memoirs of a street nurse. Altona: Friesens Press.
Davis, Mike. 2020. The Monster Enters: COVID-19, the Avian Flu and the Plagues of Capitalism. New York: Verso.
Deckha, Maneesha. 2020. “Veganism, dairy, and decolonization.” Journal of Human Rights and the Environment 11 (2): 244-267.
De Lisio, Amanda and Caroline Fusco. 2019. “Creative Destruction: Zika, Lex Sportiva and (Alleged) Bodies of Contagion.” Columbia Journal of Gender and Law 38 (1): 1-30.
Dorries, Heather. 2017. “Planning as Property: Uncovering the Hidden Racial Logic of Municipal Nuisance by-law.” Journal of Law and Social Policy 27: 72-93.
Dorries, Heather, David Hugill, and Julie Tomiak. 2022. “Racial capitalism and the production of settler colonial cities.” Geoforum 132 (June): 263-270.
FactCheck Toronto. 2020. “Claim: The City has helped more than 1,100 people move inside from encampments since the pandemic began.” https://factchecktoronto.ca/2020/12/21/claim-the-city-has-helped-more-than-1100-people-move-inside-from-encampments-since-the-pandemic-began/.
Estes, Nick. 2019. “Anti-Indian Common Sense: Border Town Violence and Resistance in Mni Luzahan.” In Settler City Limits: Indigenous Resurgence and Colonial Violence in the Urban Prairie West, edited by Heather Dorries, Robert Henry, David Hugill, Tyler McCreary and Julie Tomiak, 44-69. Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press.
Farha, Leilani and Kaitlin Schwan. 2020. “A Human Rights Approach: A National Protocol for Homeless Encampments in Canada” UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Housing. https://www.make-the-shift.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/A-National-Protocol-for-Homeless-Encampments-in-Canada.pdf.
Fischer, John Ryan. 2015. Cattle Colonialism: An Environmental History of the Conquest of California and Hawai’i. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Fortier, Tessa. 2017. “Conflicting identities of the Garrison Creek.” Master’s paper, York University.
Foucault, Michel. 1977. Discipline and Punish. New York: Pantheon.
Foucault, Michel. 1980. Power/Knowledge. New York: Pantheon.
Fusco, Caroline. 2005. “Cultural landscapes of purification: Sports spaces and discourses of whiteness.” Sociology of Sport Journal 22 (3): 282-309.
Gaetz, Stephen, Erin Dej, Tim Richter and Melanie Redman. 2018. The state of homelessness in Canada 2016. Toronto: Canadian Observatory on Homelessness Press.
Gilmore, Ruth Wilson. 2002. “Fatal couplings of power and difference: Notes on racism and geography.” The professional geographer 54, (1): 15-24.
Gilmore, Ruth Wilson. 2007. Golden gulag: Prisons, surplus, crisis, and opposition in globalizing California. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Gilmore, Ruth Wilson. Abolition geography: Essays towards liberation. Verso Books, 2022.
Grenier, Amanda. 2022. Late-life Homelessness: Experiences of Disadvantage and Unequal Aging. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s Press.
Harris, Cheryl I. 1993. “Whiteness as property.” Harvard Law Review 106 (8): 1707-1791.
Harris, Cheryl I. 2020. “Reflections on Whiteness as property.” Harvard Law Review Forum 134 (1): 1-11.
Harris, Cole. 2004. “How did colonialism dispossess? Comments from an edge of empire.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 94 (1): 165-182.
Heralt, Chris. 2021. “Trinity-Bellwoods encampment evictions ‘reasonable, firm, but compassionate:’ Tory.” CTV News, June 23, 2021. https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/trinity-bellwoods-encampment-evictions-reasonable-firm-but-compassionate-tory-1.5481959.
Hermer, Joe. 2002. Regulating Eden: the nature of order in North American parks. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Hudson-Rodd, Nancy. 1998. “Nineteenth century Canada: indigenous place of dis-ease.” Health & Place 4 (1): 55-66.
Hwang, Stephen W. 2002. “Is homelessness hazardous to your health?” Canadian Journal of Public Health 93 (6): 407-410.
Jones, Bryony A., Delia Grace, Richard Kock, Silvia Alonso, Jonathan Rushton, Mohammed Y. Said, Declan McKeever, Florence Mutua, Jarrah Young, John McDermott and Dirk Udo Pfeiffer. 2013. “Zoonosis emergence linked to agricultural intensification and environmental change.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 110 (21): 8399-8404.
Kanji, Azeezah and A.J. Withers. 2021. “Encampment evictions: Another face of colonial violence in Canada.” Aljazeera, July 20, 2021. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/7/20/encampment-evictions-another-face-of-colonial-violence-in-canada.
Kiran, Tara, Amy Craig-Neil, Paul Das, Joel Lockwood, Ri Wang, Nikki Nathanielsz, Esther Rosenthal, Carolyn Snider and Stephen W. Hwang. 2021. “Factors associated with SARS-CoV-2 positivity in 20 homeless shelters in Toronto, Canada, from April to July 2020: A repeated cross-sectional study”. Canadian Medical Association Open Access Journal 9 (1): E302-E308.
Kohn, Margaret. 2013. “Privatization and protest: Occupy Wall Street, Occupy Toronto, and the occupation of public space in a democracy.” Perspectives on Politics 11 (1): 99-110.
Liboiron, Max. 2021. Pollution is Colonialism. Cambridge: Duke University Press.
Loftus, Alex. 2009. “Rethinking political ecologies of water.” Third World Quarterly 30 (5): 953-968.
MacDougall, Heather. 1981. “Public Health in Toronto’s Municipal Politics: The Canniff Years, 1883-1890.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine 55 (2): 186-202.
Masuda, Jeffrey R., Aaron Franks, Audrey Kobayashi and Trevor Wildeman. 2020. “After dispossession: An urban rights praxis of remaining in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 38 (2): 229-247.
Martini, Natalia. 2021. “Street Homelessness, Visibility and Recognition.” ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 20 (5): 460-478.
Maynard, Robyn and Leanne Betasamosake Simpson. 2022. Rehearsals for Living. Toronto: Knopf Canada.
McCartan, Delaney, Lauren Graham, Estair Van Wagner Kaitlin Schwan and Alexandra Flynn. 2021. “Trespassing on the Right to Housing: A human rights analysis of the City of Toronto’s response to encampments during COVID-19”. Environmental Justice and Sustainability Clinic, Osgoode Hall Law School. https://ejsclinic.info.yorku.ca/2021/12/trespassing-on-the-right-to-housing-a-human-rights-analysis-of-the-city-of-torontos-response-to-encampments-during-covid-19/.
Miller, Peter and Nikolas Rose. 2008. Governing the Present: Administering Economic, Social and Personal Life. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Monaghan, Michael. 2021. “Hidden Landscapes: Revealing Toronto’s Garrison Creek Ravine.” Master’s thesis, University of British Columbia.
Moreton-Robinson, Aileen. 2015. The white possessive: Property, power, and indigenous sovereignty. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Murphy, Michelle. 2020. “Some keywords toward decolonial methods: Studying settler colonial histories and environmental violence from tkaronto.” History and Theory 59 (3): 376-384.
NDN Collective. 2022. NDN Collective Response to the IPCC Report Pointing to Colonialism as a Climate Change Driver. https://ndncollective.org/ndn-collective-repsonse-to-ipcc/.
O’Malley, Pat. 2000. “Uncertain subjects: risks, liberalism and contract.” Economy and Society 29 (4): 460-484.
la paperson. 2017. A third university is possible. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Puwar, Nirmal. 2006. Space Invaders: Race, Gender and Bodies Out of Place. New York: Berg.
Richard, Lucie, Richard Booth, Jennifer Rayner, Kristin K. Clemens, Cheryl Forchuk and Salimah Z. Shariff. 2021. “Testing, infection and complication rates of COVID-19 among people with a recent history of homeless in Ontario, Canada: a retrospective cohort study.” Canadian Medical Association Open Access Journal 9 (1): E1-E9.
Rogers, Julia H., Amy C. Link, Denise McCulloch, Elisabeth Brandstetter, Kira L. Newman, Michael L. Jackson, James P. Hughes, Janet A. Englund, Michael Boeckh, Nancy Sugg, Misja Ilcisin, Thomas R. Sibley, Kairsten Fay, Jover Lee, Peter Han, Melissa Truong, Matthew Richardson, Deborah A. Nickerson, Lea M. Starita, Trevor Bedford and Helen Y. Chu. 2021. “Characteristics of COVID-19 in homeless shelters: a community-based surveillance study.” Annals of Internal Medicine 174 (1): 42-49.
Rose, Nicholas. 1999. Powers of freedom: Reframing political thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rowan Sarah E., David W. McCormick, Karen A. Wendel, Tracy Scott, Jesse Chavez-van de Hey, Kay Wilcox, Sarah A. Stella, Kevin Kamis, William J. Burman, and Grace E. Marx. 2022. “Lower Prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among People Experiencing Homelessness Tested in Outdoor Encampments Compared with Overnight Shelters–Denver, Colorado, June–July 2020.” Clinical Infectious Diseases 75 (1): e157-e164.
Sanctuary Ministries of Toronto, Aboriginal Legal Services, Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario, Black Legal Action Centre, Canadian Civil Liberties Association, HIV & AIDS Legal Clinic Ontario v. City of Toronto, ONSC 6207, CV-20-640061 (Toronto, October 1, 2020).
Sky, Blue, Leaders from the Houseless Community, Sandra Campbell, and Leigh Kern. 2022. “The Housing Crisis and the Indian Residential School Legacy.” In Displacement City: Fighting for Health and Homes in a Pandemic, edited by Greg Cook and Cathy Crowe, 7-29. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Stein, Samuel. 2019. Capital city: Gentrification and the real estate state. London & Brooklyn: Verso Books.
Speer, Jessie and Eric Goldfischer. 2020. “The city is not innocent: Homelessness and the value of urban parks.” Capitalism Nature Socialism 31 (3): 24-41.
Tabobondung, Rebeka. 2016. “Wasauking–Vancouver–Toronto: My Path Home.” Subdivided: City-Building in an Age of Hyper-Diversity, edited by Jay Pitter and John Lorinc, 46-54. Toronto: Coach House Books.
Tuck, Eve and K. Wayne Yang. 2012. “Decolonization is not a metaphor.” Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education & Society 1 (1): 1-40.
Venn, David. 2020. “‘Dangerous and selfish behaviour’: Trinity Bellwoods Park crowd spark outrage, mayor to send more officers Sunday.” Toronto Star, May 25, 2020. https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2020/05/23/dangerous-and-selfish-behaviour-a-day-after-mayor-medical-officer-urges-social-distancing-dozens-gather-at-trinity-bellwoods.html.
Walks, Alan and Susanne Soederberg. 2021. “The New Urban Displacements? Finance-Led Capitalism, Austerity, and Rental Housing Dynamics.” Urban Geography 42 (5): 571-582.
Wallace, Rob. 2016. Big farms make big flue: Dispatches on influenza, agribusiness, and the nature of science. New York: NYU Press.
Wallace, Rob. 2020. Dead epidemiologists: On the origins of COVID-19. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Weinstein, Liza. 2014. The Durable Slum: Dharavi and the Right to Stay Put in Globalizing Mumbai. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Withers, A.J. and Derrick Black. 2022. “In the parks and in the courts: the Legal Fight against Encampment Evictions.” In Displacement City: Fighting for Health and Homes in a Pandemic, edited by Greg Cook and Cathy Crowe, 211-219. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Wilson, Kerrisa. 2017. “Premier Ford reverses decision to close playgrounds amid backlash.” CP24, April 17, 2021. https://www.cp24.com/news/premier-ford-reverses-decision-to-close-playgrounds-amid-backlash-1.5391532.
Withers, A.J. & Amie Tsang. 2022. “Where there’s smoke, there’s no fire.” Briarpatch Magazine, April 30, 2022. https://briarpatchmagazine.com/articles/view/where-theres-smoke-theres-no-fire.
Wolfe, Patrick. 2006. “Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native.” Journal of Genocide Research 8 (4): 387-409.
Woodworth, Steph and Caroline Fusco. 2021. “Decolonizing autoethnography in kinesiology: Towards decolonial water education.” The Journal of School & Society 7 (1): 91-110.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Amanda De Lisio (she/they), Steph Woodworth (they/them), Raiya Thomure (they/them), Caroline Fusco (she/her)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Authors agree to publish their articles in ACME under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-
