Holy Cow! Beef Ban, Political Technologies, and Brahmanical Supremacy in Modi’s India

  • Aparna Parikh Dartmouth College
  • Clara Miller Pennsylvania State University
Keywords: surveillance, co-production, animal symbolism, Dalit, Muslim, India, South Asia

Abstract

This article focuses on political technologies applied in response to India’s contemporary beef ban and ensuing violence. The beef ban, enacted in several Indian states, prevents the slaughter, consumption, and trade of cow meat. Aided by rising Hindu nationalism, the enforcement of this ban has occurred through state and extra-state entities, the latter of which is constituted by cow vigilante groups. Such enforcement – often based on “suspicion” of cow meat possession – has resulted in horrific violence, including arrests, beatings, and lynchings of individuals belonging primarily to Muslim and Dalit communities. In response to the beef ban and associated violence, political technologies like beef detection kits and cattle unique-identification numbers are being introduced. We examine these technologies and accompanying discourse to analyze their role in producing hierarchies. We show the symbolic role of the “sacred” cow in justifying cow protectionism and vigilantism, and how such rhetoric works to objectify cows and obscure violence they face during life and death, while panoptically governing human populations. We analyze how political technologies employed under the beef ban exacerbate marginality of oppressed populations across the human-nonhuman spectrum. We contend these technologies normalize the ideology underpinning the beef ban, heighten and atomize surveillance of marginalized groups, and weaken their already-fraught place in the nation. Within the landscape of perilous Hindu nationalism, we show how a mutual avowal lens can help recognize shared vulnerability and proffer ethical forms of engagements between entangled subject positions.

References

Abraham, Delna, and Ojaswi Rao. 2017. “Cow-Related Violence: 86% Dead Since 2010 Are Muslim; 97% Attacks Reported After 2014.” The Wire, June 28, 2017. https://thewire.in/152159/cow-related-violence/.

Ambedkar, B. R. 1948. “Untouchability, the Dead Cow and the Brahmin.” In The Untouchables: Who Were They and Why They Became Untouchables. Reprint: Volume 7, Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Writings and Speeches. Government of Maharashtra.

Anand, Utkarsh. 2017a. “Aadhaar for Cattle? Each Cow, Progeny Should Get ‘Unique Identification Number’, Centre Tells SC.” The Indian Express, April 24, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/aadhaar-for-cattle-each-cow-progency-should-get-unique-identification-number-for-tracking-centre-tells-sc-4626063/.

———. 2017b. “Centre Wants UID for All Cows with Details of Horn, Tail, Breed, Age.” The Indian Express, April 25, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/centre-wants-uid-for-all-cows-with-details-of-horn-tail-breed-age-4626717/.

Arunima, G. 2015. “Of Cows, Muslims, and the Right to Religious Difference.” Economic & Political Weekly 50 (40). https://www.epw.in/journal/2015/40/web-exclusives/cows-muslims-and-right-religious-difference.html.

Ashraf, Ajaz. 2015a. “Beef Ban Is an Attempt to Impose Upper-Caste Culture on Other Hindus: Kancha Ilaiah.” Scroll.In, March 19, 2015. http://scroll.in/article/714661/beef-ban-is-an-attempt-to-impose-upper-caste-culture-on-other-hindus-kancha-ilaiah.

———. 2015b. “History Is Proof Most Hindus Never Had Any Beef with Beef.” Quartz, March 21, 2015. https://qz.com/366659/history-says-most-hindus-never-had-any-beef-with-beef/.

———. 2017. “Why Hindu Farmers and Cattle Traders in Rajasthan Are Angry with Gau Rakshaks.” Scroll.In, 2017. https://scroll.in/article/836477/why-hindu-farmers-and-cattle-traders-in-rajasthan-are-angry-with-gau-rakshaks.

Banerjee, Poulomi. 2015. “Meat of the Matter: How Beef Ban Affects Leather, Exports and Chemical Industry.” Hindustan Times, March 22, 2015. http://www.hindustantimes.com/india/meat-of-the-matter-how-beef-ban-affects-leather-exports-and-chemical-industry/story-q6qLCPfV2hpijG0xSHQNGJ.html.

Bhardwaj, Mayank. 2017. “Cattle Trade Ban Could Half Beef Exports, Lead to Job Losses.” LiveMint, May 29, 2017. http://www.livemint.com/Politics/2REzm02p1jsRhbG9uFLG3K/Cattle-trade-ban-could-half-beef-exports-lead-to-job-losses.html.

Bhatia, Rahul. 2018. “Critics of Aadhaar Say They Are Under Surveillance, Allege Government Harassment.” The Wire, 2018. https://thewire.in/economy/critics-aadhaar-say-surveillance-allege-government-harassment.

Brass, Paul R. 2011. The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence in Contemporary India. University of Washington Press.

Cherian, Viju. 2018. “Aadhaar-like Tags for Cows: Does Govt’s Intent Match Ground Realities?” Hindustan Times, February 6, 2018. https://www.hindustantimes.com/opinion/aadhaar-like-tags-for-cows-does-govt-s-intent-match-ground-realities/story-mTIYDI1sd0NFGDFf0HAcYP.html.

Choudhury, Rabindra Nath. 2018. “MP Completes UID Tagging of 2.5 Lakh Cattle.” Asian Age, March 26, 2018. http://www.asianage.com/india/all-india/260318/mp-completes-uid-tagging-of-25-lakh-cattle.html.

Daniyal, Shoaib. 2015a. “Between Banned Beef and Expensive Dal, How Are Poor Indians Supposed to Get Enough Protein?” Text. Scroll.In. 2015. http://scroll.in/article/765001/between-banned-beef-and-expensive-dal-how-are-poor-indians-supposed-to-get-enough-protein.

———. 2015b. “Gosht Busters: Five Examples of India’s Tragi-Comic Obsession with Vegetarianism.” Scroll.In, September 13, 2015. http://scroll.in/article/755126/gosht-busters-five-examples-of-indias-tragi-comic-obsession-with-vegetarianism.

Das, Kalyan. 2015. “To Eat or Not To Eat Beef.” Economic & Political Weekly 50 (44). https://www.epw.in/journal/2015/44/special-articles/eat-or-not-eat-beef.html.

Dube, Mukul. 2015. “Why Do We Insist on Calling India a Vegetarian Country When Two-Thirds of Us Eat Meat?” Scroll.In, June 15, 2015. https://scroll.in/article/734242/why-do-we-insist-on-calling-india-a-vegetarian-country-when-two-thirds-of-us-eat-meat.

“ELISA: Purpose, Procedure, and Results.” 2012. Healthline. July 19, 2012. https://www.healthline.com/health/elisa.
Engineer, Rayomond. 2017. “India Has Tagged Lakhs of Sheep & Cows. Here’s Why It Is a Good Move.” The Better India, December 18, 2017. https://www.thebetterindia.com/124759/tagging-animals-india-monitoring/.

Express Web Desk. 2017. “Cow Dung Can Be Used to Make Bunkers: RSS Leader Indresh Kumar.” The Indian Express, August 2, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/rss-leader-indresh-kumar-calls-cow-meat-as-poison-says-dung-can-be-used-to-make-bunkers-4779363/.

Fang, Yi, and Ramaraja P. Ramasamy. 2015. “Current and Prospective Methods for Plant Disease Detection.” Biosensors 5 (3): 537. https://doi.org/10.3390/bios5030537.

Fazal, Imran. 2017. “UP, MP May Buy Maha’s Instant Beef-Testing Kits.” Daily News and Analysis, August 16, 2017. http://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/report-up-mp-may-buy-maha-s-instant-beef-testing-kits-2531209.

First Post Staff. 2017. “Life Imprisonment for Cow Slaughter, Makes Gujarat the State with Harshest Laws on Beef Ban.”
Firstpost, March 31, 2017. https://www.firstpost.com/politics/life-imprisonment-for-cow-slaughter-makes-gujarat-the-state-with-harshest-laws-on-beef-ban-3361958.html.

Foucault, Michel. 1977. “Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison.” Trans. Sheridan A. Penguin Books. London.

Ganguly, Sumit. 2003. “The Crisis of Indian Secularism.” Journal of Democracy 14 (4): 11–25. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2003.0076.

Ghoshal, Somak. 2017. “Beef Detection Kits May Save Time And Funds But Are Unlikely To Save Lives.” Huffington Post India, July 10, 2017. http://www.huffingtonpost.in/2017/07/10/beef-detection-kits_a_23023245/.

Goldman, Michael. 2005. Imperial Nature: The World Bank and Struggles for Social Justice in the Age of Globalization. Yale University Press.

Haq, Zia. 2018. “40 Million Cows to Get Aadhaar-like Number at Cost of Rs 50 Crore in 1st Phase.” Hindustan Times, February 3, 2018. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/40-million-cows-to-get-aadhaar-like-number-at-cost-of-rs-50-crore-in-1st-phase/story-9f50M1CkgBoCSym5SR1VzL.html.

Ilaiah, Kancha. 1996. “Beef, BJP and Food Rights of People.” Economic & Political Weekly 31 (24). https://www.epw.in/journal/1996/24/commentary/beef-bjp-and-food-rights-people.html.

“IndiaSpend | Hate-Crime Database.” n.d. Accessed July 8, 2018. http://data.indiaspend.com/hate-crime.
IndiaSpend Staff. 2017. “26 Cases Of Cow-Related Violence In 7 Months Of 2017, Equalling 2016 As Worst Year.” IndiaSpend, July 28, 2017. http://www.indiaspend.com/cover-story/26-cases-of-cow-related-violence-in-7-months-of-2017-equalling-2016-as-worst-year-21119.

IndiaTimes Staff. 2018. “An Online Researcher Hacked Into Aadhaar’s Official Android App To Show How Poorly It’s Secured.” Indiatimes, 2018. https://www.indiatimes.com/technology/news/an-online-researcher-hacked-into-aadhaar-s-official-android-app-to-show-how-poorly-it-s-secured-337425.html.

IndiaTimes Staff. 2017. “Six Muslim Men Beaten Up By Vigilantes, Arrested In Bihar On Suspicion Of Cow Slaughter.” IndiaTimes, August 19, 2017. http://www.indiatimes.com/news/india/six-muslim-men-beaten-up-by-vigilantes-arrested-in-bihar-on-suspicion-of-cow-slaughter-328111.html.

Jaffrelot, Christophe. 2017. “India’s Democracy at 70: Toward a Hindu State?” Journal of Democracy 28 (3): 52–63. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2017.0044.

Jain, Shruti. 2017. “Jaipur’s Meat Sellers Living in Fear After Intimidation, Licence Crackdown.” The Wire, May 20, 2017. https://thewire.in/137877/jaipur-meat-sellers-crackdown/.

Jaiswal, Anuja. 2017. “Now, Slaughterhouses in UP Told to Install Ultrasound Machines, CCTV Cameras - Times of India.” The Times of India, 2017. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/agra/now-slaughterhouses-in-up-told-to-install-ultrasound-machines-cctv-cameras/articleshow/61632487.cms.

Jasanoff, Sheila. 2004. “The Idiom of Co-Production.” States of Knowledge: The Co-Production of Science and Social Order, 1–12.

Johari, Aarefa. 2014. “Liberal ‘Hindu’ Newspaper Reiterates No-Meat Policy in Office, Sparks Debate on Vegetarian Fundamentalism.” Scroll.In, 2014. http://scroll.in/article/662132/liberal-hindu-newspaper-reiterates-no-meat-policy-in-office-sparks-debate-on-vegetarian-fundamentalism.

———. 2015. “Fearing Loss of Livelihood, Maharashtra’s Meat Traders Prepare to Protest Beef Ban.” Scroll.In, March 4, 2015. http://scroll.in/article/711220/fearing-loss-of-livelihood-maharashtras-meat-traders-prepare-to-protest-beef-ban.

Kazmin, Amy. 2017. “Modi’s India: The High Cost of Protecting Holy Cows.” Financial Times, November 22, 2017. https://www.ft.com/content/63522f50-caf3-11e7-ab18-7a9fb7d6163e.

Khalid, Saif. 2018. “As Assam Counts Its Citizens, Muslims Fear They May Be Left Out.” Al Jazeera, May 31, 2018. https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/assam-counts-citizens-muslims-fear-left-180530080633948.html.

Khan, Aamir. 2017. “What the Bombay High Court Verdict on Beef Ban Means.” The Indian Express, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/decoded-what-the-bombay-hc-verdict-on-beef-ban-means-2788254/.

Kotak, Yesha. 2018. “Mumbai Meat Shop Owners Demand Use of Portable Kits to Detect Meat Type.” Hindustan Times, 2018. https://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai-news/mumbai-meat-shop-owners-demand-use-of-portable-kits-to-detect-meat-type/story-edMSLnXPddJTmCMkBWTxmN.html.

Krishnan, Murali. 2017. “In Pehlu Khan’s Village, Fear, Dismay and Anger Linger.” The Wire, 2017. https://thewire.in/134774/pehlu-khan-cattle-vigilante/.

Kulkarni, Prachee. 2017. “After Beef Ban, Meat-Seller Takes to Vending Vegetables.” The Times of India, 2017. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/after-beef-ban-meat-seller-takes-to-vending-vegetables/articleshow/59722486.cms.

Mandal, Bankim Chandra. 2010. “Caste Discrimination, Deprivation and the Socio-Economic Development of Dalits:” Contemporary Voice of Dalit, July. https://doi.org/10.1177/0974354520100203.

Minhaz, Ayesha. 2015. “Beyond Beef and Pork Festivals: The Fight for Public Space in the Osmania University Campus.” Scroll.In, 2015. http://scroll.in/article/774629/beyond-beef-and-pork-festivals-the-fight-for-public-space-in-the-osmania-university-campus.

Mitchell, Timothy. 2002. Rule of Experts: Egypt, Techno-Politics, Modernity. University of California Press.

Mohanty, Abhijit. 2017. “Photo Essay: India’s Silent Emergency – Malnutrition.” The Wire, 2017. https://thewire.in/187910/photo-essay-indias-silent-emergency-malnutrition/.

Nair, Gayatri. 2016. “The Bitter Aftertaste of Beef Ban.” Economic & Political Weekly. https://www.epw.in/journal/2016/10/commentary/bitter-aftertaste-beef-ban.html.

Narayanan, Yamini. "Cow Protection as ‘Casteised Speciesism’: Sacralisation, Commercialisation and Politicisation." South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 41, no. 2 (2018): 331-351.

Natrajan, Balmurli, and Suraj Jacob. 2018. “‘Provincialising’ Vegetarianism.” Economic & Political Weekly 53 (9). https://www.epw.in/journal/2018/9/special-articles/provincialising-vegetarianism.html.

Pavan, P. 2017. “Meet the Vegetarian Scientist Who Devised the Maharashtra Government’s Cow-Meat Detection Kit.” Bangalore Mirror, 2017. http://bangaloremirror.indiatimes.com/columns/sunday-read/meet-the-vegetarian-scientist-who-devised-the-maharashtra-governments-cow-meat-detection-kit/articleshow/59716738.cms.

Pokharel, Sugam, and James Griffiths. 2018. “India WhatsApp Rumors: Mob Kills Man in Latest Attack, 30 Arrested.” CNN, July 16, 2018. https://www.cnn.com/2018/07/16/asia/india-whatsapp-lynching-intl/index.html.

Press Trust of India. 2017. “Cops to Get ‘Beef Detection Kits.’” The Hindu, 2017. http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/cops-to-get-beef-detection-kits/article19244149.ece.

———. 2018a. “250,000 Cattle in MP Stamped with Unique 12-Digit Aadhaar-like Number.” Business Standard India, 2018. http://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/250-000-cattle-in-mp-stamped-with-unique-12-digit-aadhaar-like-number-118032500336_1.html.

———. 2018b. “Kerala Govt to Geotag 10 Lakh Livestock Farmer Houses.” India Today, 2018. https://www.indiatoday.in/pti-feed/story/ker-govt-to-geotag-10-lakh-livestock-farmer-houses-1172212-2018-02-18.

———. 2018c. “Madhya Pradesh Completes UID Tagging of 2.5 Lakh Cattle.” Hindustan Times, 2018.
https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/madhya-pradesh-completes-uid-tagging-of-2-5-lakh-cattle/story-L4LFwVF04IAq61Gi2qJvaN.html.

———. 2018d. “Digitisation Drive: Kerala Govt to Geotag 10 Lakh Livestock Farmer Houses.” The Indian Express (blog). February 18, 2018. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala-govt-to-geotag-10-lakh-livestock-farmer-houses-5068679/.
“Protest Diaries: Not in My Name, Break the Silence and More.” 2017. Economic and Political Weekly 52 (25–26).
https://www.epw.in/journal/2017/25-26/web-exclusives/not-my-name-protests-against-mob-lynching-cow-slaughter.html.

Raento, Pauliina. 2016. “A Geopolitics of the Horse in Finland.” Geopolitics 21 (4): 945–968.

Rather, Shaiba. 2016. “Student Voices: Beef Bans in India.” Harvard South Asia Institute Blog (blog). 2016. http://harvardsai.tumblr.com/post/153007075070/student-voices-beef-bans-in-india.

Robbins, Paul. 1999. “Meat Matters: Cultural Politics along the Commodity Chain in India.” Ecumene 6 (4): 399–423. https://doi.org/10.1177/096746089900600402.

Roberts, Nathaniel. 2016. To Be Cared for: The Power of Conversion and Foreignness of Belonging in an Indian Slum. Vol. 20. University of California Press.

Saleem, Shaikh Zoaib. 2018. “Aadhaar Is Still Mandatory for New Bank Accounts.” LiveMint, May 1, 2018.
https://www.livemint.com/Money/QZPvuAyYKaJLl2gbnI5sZM/Aadhaar-is-still-mandatory-for-new-bank-accounts.html.

Samarajeewa, U., C. I. Wei, T. S. Huang, and M. R. Marshall. 2009. “Application of Immunoassay in the Food Industry.” Critical Reviews in Food Science & Nutrition, September. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408399109527535.

Scroll Staff. 2017a. “Pregnant Women Should Avoid Eating Meat, Not Have Sex, Says Ayush Ministry: Report.” Scroll.In, 2017. https://scroll.in/latest/840529/pregnant-women-should-avoid-eating-meat-not-have-sex-says-ayush-ministry-report.

———. 2017b. “IIT Madras PhD Scholar Beaten up by Students for Participating in Beef Fest.” Text. Scroll.In. March 30, 2017. https://scroll.in/latest/839161/iit-madras-phd-scholar-beaten-up-by-students-for-participating-in-beef-fest.

———. 2017c. “Every Cow Should Get a Unique Identification Number for Tracking, Suggests Centre.” Text. Scroll.In. April 24, 2017. https://scroll.in/latest/835479/every-cow-should-get-a-unique-identification-number-for-tracking-suggests-centre.

———. 2018. “French Researcher Uses Simple Hack to Access Telangana Government Site with Lakhs of Aadhaar Details.” Scroll.In, 2018. https://scroll.in/latest/870154/french-researcher-uses-simple-hack-to-access-telangana-government-site-with-lakhs-of-aadhaar-details.

Shaikh, Farhan. 2017. “Beef Ban: Maharashtra to Get ‘Detection Kits’ to Identify Meat within 30 Minutes.” Hindustan Times, July 7, 2017. http://www.hindustantimes.com/mumbai-news/beef-ban-maharashtra-to-get-detection-kits-to-identify-meat-within-30-minutes/story-1tOo6eWkQRdsyeCT05tgZJ.html.

Shaikh, Zeeshan. 2017. “Maharashtra Bans Beef, 5 Years Jail, Rs 10,000 Fine for Possession or Sale.” The Indian Express, January 27, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/beef-banned-in-maharashtra-5-yrs-jail-rs10000-fine-for-possession-or-sale/.

Sharma, Diwakar. 2018. “Mumbai: Forensic Scientists Will Conduct Beef Tests in Mobile Vans Stationed in Every District.” Free Press Journal, February 23, 2018. http://www.freepressjournal.in/mumbai/mumbai-forensic-scientists-will-conduct-beef-tests-in-mobile-vans-stationed-in-every-district/1226084.

Sharma, Rini. 2017. “Aadhaar-like Number for Cows? Cattle Should Get Unique Identification Number, Centre Tells SC.” India.Com, April 24, 2017. http://www.india.com/news/india/aadhaar-like-number-for-cows-cattle-should-get-unique-identification-number-centre-tells-sc-2061643/.

Shepherd, Kancha Ilaiah. 2018. “Opinion: Repealing Cow Protection Laws Should Be an Election Issue in 2019.” Scroll.In, 2018. https://scroll.in/article/868067/opinion-the-opposition-must-make-repealing-cow-protection-laws-an-election-issue-in-2019.

Sukumar, N. 2015. “Why Beef Was Banished From My Kitchen.” Economic & Political Weekly 50 (17). https://www.epw.in/journal/2015/17/web-exclusives/why-beef-was-banished-my-kitchen.html.

TA, Johnson. 2017. “IIT Kharagpur Graduate Hacked Aadhaar Data through Digital India App: Police.” The Indian Express, August 4, 2017. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/iit-grad-hacked-aadhaar-data-through-digital-india-app-cops-4781447/.

The Editorial Board. 2017. “India’s Turn Toward Intolerance.” The New York Times, July 17, 2017. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/17/opinion/indias-turn-toward-intolerance.html?nytmobile=0.

Thorat, Sukhadeo, and Paul Attewell. 2007. “The Legacy of Social Exclusion: A Correspondence Study of Job Discrimination in India.” Economic and Political Weekly 42 (41): 4141–45.

Thorat, Sukhadeo, Anuradha Banerjee, Vinod K. Mishra, and Firdaus Rizvi. 2015. “Urban Rental Housing Market.” Economic & Political Weekly 27: 47–53.

TNN. 2012. “Narendra Modi Tells US Daily: Gujarat’s Malnutrition Due to Figure-Conscious Girls.” The Times of India. August 29, 2012. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Narendra-Modi-tells-US-daily-Gujarats-malnutrition-due-to-figure-conscious-girls/articleshow/15948509.cms.

———. 2017. “Two Dalit Youths Lynched to Death in Bihar.” The Times of India, June 30, 2017.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/patna/two-dalit-youths-lynched-to-death-in-bihar/articleshow/59379199.cms.

Vaktania, Saurabh. 2017. “Maharashtra FSL Develops Mobile Kit for Cow Meat Testing.” India Today, July 10, 2017. https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/maharashtra-fsl-elisa-kit-cow-meat-beef-testing-1023450-2017-07-10.

Venkataramakrishnan, Rohan. 2017. “The Daily Fix: The Airtel-Aadhaar Mess-up Shows Why Criticism of the UID Must Be Taken Seriously.” Scroll.In, 2017. https://scroll.in/article/862222/the-daily-fix-the-airtel-aadhaar-mess-up-shows-why-criticism-of-the-uid-must-be-taken-seriously.

Venkateswaran, Vikram. 2017. “Decoded: Cattle Market Rules, ‘Beef Ban.’” The Quint, June 13, 2017. https://www.thequint.com/explainers/2017/06/13/cattle-market-rules-are-farmers-bane-but-its-more-complicated-than-that-detailed-q-and-a.

Walker, John M. 1987. “The Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA).” Techniques in Molecular Biology, 82–97. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-9799-5_4.
Published
2019-09-12
How to Cite
Parikh, Aparna, and Clara Miller. 2019. “Holy Cow! Beef Ban, Political Technologies, and Brahmanical Supremacy in Modi’s India”. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 18 (4), 835-74. https://acme-journal.org/index.php/acme/article/view/1758.